SOTR1949 - Secrets of the Third Reich

 
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • Increase font size
Home
Hitler's Miracle Weapons: Volume 2 PDF Print E-mail
Written by Michael Cannon   
Sunday, 16 November 2008
vol2.jpgHitler's Miracle Weapons: The Secret History of the Rockets and Flying Craft of the Third Reich
Volume 2: From the V-1 to the A-9: Unconventional short- and medium range weapons

Friedrich Georg

This is the second volume of Georg's work on Hitler's secret weapons (the title above is taken directly from the book!) Although the focus here is strictly on rockets and missles, there is necessarily some overlap with Volume 1 when he talks about delivery systems. Once again, Georg argues that contrary to the popular historical interpretation that Hitler's V-weapons were costly diversions from the war effort, the V-weapons actually had a great effect on the conduct of the war in 1944 and 1945 and, had the projects that were underway come to fruition, could have brought about a stalemate in the war.

One of the things limiting detailed research on this topic is the lack of information released on German prototype weapons. Gerog claims that out of the 138 rocket and missile systems under development we lack information on over 80 of them. Georg claims that the V-weapons had their roots in the attempts by German scientists to develop weapons that could strike back at Allied forces in 1918! Fokker and other companies were doing their best to produce radio-controlled gliders that could be steered into targets. Moreover, many German thinkers viewed these weapons as a means to strike at the US using Zeppelins and guided craft. Georg goes so far as to claim that between the wars, German scientists looked into rockets as a way to circumvent restrictions on German heavy artillery limitations imposed by the Treaty of Versailles. In fact, the US was aware of this research as early as 1922 when BG Billy Mitchell and a couple of advisors met with several of the German researchers looking into rocket propellant!

These weapons came into being at Peenemünde in WW2. Peenemünde -Ost was the Army's testing center and at Peenemünde-West was the Luftwaffe's test center. The Army had focused on rockets and their derivatives, new types of artillery, and nuclear weapons development. The Luftwaffe on unconventional propulsion systems, weapons technolohgies, rocket-propulsion systems and high energy propellants. These were state-of-the-art facilities, and Georg claims that there were two specialized TV transmission stations that broadcast to control rooms over broadband cabling. As early as 1938, the Germans were using one of the first binary computers in the world to assist with ballistic calculations. In July of 44, however, all of this came under the control of the SS and was commanded by Dr. Hans Kammler. (Kammler is a particularly unpleasant individual whose influence is felt throughout the Reich in the latter part of the war and figures prominently in the arguments of those who study German super-science.) These changes in command dovetailed with a change in strategy that took place in 1943.

The first strategy was for the SS, with the help of foreign volunteers and the newly created SS Panzer and Panzer Grenadier divisions, to hold the enemy as far as possible away from the borders of Germany during the period from 1944 to 1946. Meanwhile, it was planned to push forward mass production of the new miracle weapons. This included new jet aircraft and rockets which would be far more effective than the  later V-1 and V-2 Vergeltungswaffen. These new weapons systems would - so it was hoped -put Germany in the position of being able to begin a new, decisive offensive in 1947.

The German rocket program was among the most expensive weapons programs to have been developed as of 1944, Georg claiming that the V-1 and V-2 programs cost 3 Billion dollars. This meant that each V-1 cost 50,000 dollars and each V-2 500,000! What this massive amount of money brought was only 20,000 tons of explosives rained down on enemy targets. Strategically, this program forced the Allies to divert their attack from the broad-front approach favored by Eisenhower to the thrust Montgomery carried out in Market-Garden to deprive the Germans of their launch sites in range of England. That the V-weapons could be effective is shown by the bombardment of Antwerp. Allied estimates were that the transport capability was reduced to only 25% of its potential in the later part of the war.

Why were such limited amounts of explosives so successful? Georg offers the following:

In heavily built-up areas of London, a single V-2 rocket could destroy or damage 600 houses. In doing so, it was not the blast or the effect of the explosive which was the decisive factor, but the massive shaking of the earth. The impact momentum of a V-2 was the same as if 50 loco­motives each weighing 100 tons had struck each other simultaneously at a speed of 100 kilometres per hour. And because it was not possible to give any warning of the V-2, their impacts led to great indirect economic losses in the form of lost working hours and of workers not turning up at their places of work. According to British reports, these effects involving interruptions to production and adverse effects on working discipline in London were more serious than the destructive effect of the explosive charge in Hitler's second V-weapon.

And it was precisely this weapon which was to have a dia­bolical effect on the further course of the Second World War.

On 7 September 1944, the first phase of the 'battle of London' had come to an end with the loss of the German V-1 launch bases in France to the advancing Allied troops. Only one day later, however, a new chapter in the history of Hitler's 'push-button warfare' began with the launch of the V-2 rockets against London from Dutch bases in the vicinity of the Hague.

Witnesses to the rocket impacts in Britain described "an explosion which sounded like a clap of thunder, which was immediately followed by the sound of a heavy body rushing through the air". The inhabitants of London could not explain these explosions, because neither German air­craft nor V-ls had been seen beforehand. But remarkably, neither the British Government nor the leadership of the Third Reich gave any explanation in the subsequent two months as to the cause of these explosions which increas­ingly shook southern Britain.

Georg claims, however, that these early programs were merely testbeds for more advanced projects designed to carry nuclear warheads. Georg quotes Hans Rudel as a source.

Then, in March 1944, Hitler then made an unequivocal statement about the real purpose of his V-weapons pro­gramme. Oberst Hans-Ulrich Rudel gives an account of this in his book Trotzdem. Hitler had a high regard for the young Luftwaffe officer and placed special confidence in him. He was even able, later, to present Rudel as a suitable candidate to succeed him.

On 29 March 1944, at the Oberberghof in Berchtesgaden, Rudel received from Hitler and the distinguished military decoration of the Knight's Cross with Diamonds. Rudel then describes what happened after he received the decora­tion. "We were drinking tea together and talking for anoth­er two hours. Innovations in weapons technology, the war situation and history are the main topics of conversation. He made particular mention to me of the V-weapons, which we have just begun to deploy. People should not overestimate the effect of these weapons at the present time, said Hitler, because the accuracy of the missiles was still very poor. But, he went on, this would not always be the case, because at the moment all he wanted was to have rockets which were able to fly without any problem. Later, Hitler said, there would be an explosive which was like no normal explosive such as we know at the moment, but something entirely different, which would be powerful enough to effect a positive outcome to the war. He said that the development of this explosive was far advanced, and that it would soon go into production. For me, all this is completely new territory, and I can't imagine what he is talking about. Later, I hear that the explosive power of the new rocket will be based on atomic power".

This means that, in Hitler's own words, the V-1 was to be armed with nuclear warheads as well as the V-2.

In comparison with normal bombers, the unmanned missiles and rockets had the disadvantage that they could only carry a payload between 850 and 1000 kilograms.
 
If their payload was so limited, then how could the V-weapons change the course of the war, despite the descriptions of the V-2 attacks above. Georg is convinced that the V-weapons were going to be equipped with nuclear weapons.

I find his argument to be pretty compelling. The latter half of the book is devoted to descriptions of weapons, bomb designs, and more, adding to the credibility of his thesis. The points Georg makes are well illustrated with both contemporary artwork and period documents (these include several diagrams of bombs interiors and underground launch and research facilities).

What does this signify for the Weird War enthusiast? If you can get past the V-Gas/Zombie issue, there was a very real chance that had the war gone on longer the world would have seen more nuclear combat with the possibility of biological weapons deployment.  The reality of combat in 46 or 47 could well have been like that of SOTR1949....
Comments
Add NewSearch
Only registered users can write comments!

Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.

Last Updated ( Saturday, 27 December 2008 )
 
Next >

SOTR1949 Login

Magazine Issues

Issue 3
Issue 2
Issue 1

Featured Article

US Armored Infantry
US Armored Infantry
Back in the late 70s or early 80s, Duke Seifried evangelized the use of washes in painting miniatures. Once again he was ahead of his time. Lately, Dr. Phil Hendry has been doing something similar for Warlord Games with his use of Army Painter products and dipping. Now back in Texas there are really only two kinds of dip - one for sheep and one for the lower lip. I liked Phil's results, however, and decided to give it a shot with my US Armored infantry platoon.
Read More >>

Syndicate

Who's Online